Author: Marshall Barker
Understanding acceptable circuit breaker operating temperatures will help avoid unnecessary replacements and returns. A circuit breaker that is warm to the touch, or too hot to touch, is normally within acceptable operating temperatures. Therefore, it is important to obtain the temperature reading on the circuit breaker rather than going by touch. Non-metallic handles, knobs, and other user contact surfaces are allowed to reach a maximum temperature of 185ºF (85ºC) per Underwriters Laboratories® (UL®).
|Acceptable Operating Temperatures are Defined by UL 489
The acceptable operating temperature of a circuit breaker is defined by UL in the UL489 Standard (reference Jan. 2013), which is summarized in the table below.
Terminations for standard rated circuit breakers: Paragraph 188.8.131.52.2 says the temperature rise on a wiring terminal at a point to which the insulation of a wire is brought up as in actual service shall not exceed 90ºF (50ºC).
Terminations for 100% rated circuit breakers: Paragraph 184.108.40.206.3 says the temperature rise on the termination service shall not exceed 108ºF (60ºC).
Handles, knobs, and other user surfaces: Paragraph 220.127.116.11.6 says the maximum temperature on handles, knobs, and other surfaces subject to user contact during normal operation shall not exceed 140ºF (60ºC) on metallic and 185ºF (85ºC) on nonmetallic surfaces.
Where does the heat come from, and how is it calculated? The normal heat generators inside the circuit breaker are the main contacts, bi-metal for tripping, electronics and power supplies, causing the circuit breaker body to increase in temperature. The body of the circuit breaker can be hotter than the terminations, since the load wires act as heat sinks (see Figure at left). Each circuit breaker family or frame will have its own heating characteristics due to different designs, so not all circuit breakers run at the same temperature.
The amount of heat a circuit breaker generates from pole resistance (watts loss) can be calculated with the following formula: P = I^2 x R, where:
P = Watts loss per pole, in watts
I = Load current in amperes
R = Pole resistance in ohms.
The pole resistance (in micro ohms) for many circuit breakers can be found in the Field Testing and Maintenance Guide 0600IB1201.
Commercial Example: from page 17 of the aforementioned Instruction Bulletin, the pole
resistance for a PowerPact™ H-Frame 15 A circuit breaker is
35,000 micro ohms. Convert that to 0.035 Ohms. Now using the formula:
The circuit breaker in this example generates or loses 7.9 watts per pole. For a three-pole circuit breaker 7.9 watt x 3 poles = 23.6 watts.
Residential Example: the
QO120CAFI combination arc fault circuit breaker generates approximately
2.2 W from resistance and 0.8 W from the on-board electronics, for
a total of 3 W. 3 W is considerably lower than the heat generated
by the home wiring, for example, a 20 A load through fifty feet of
#12 AWG Cu wire generates approximately 32 watts, due to resistance
(1.6 Ohms per 1000 ft.). The wire stays cooler because it dissipates
the heat over the length of the wire. Compared to the home wiring,
the circuit breakers generate very little “heat”, even
though the circuit breaker temperature is higher, since the heat is
Scan showing Normal Temperatures of Circuit Breakers in a Load Center
NOTE: Temperatures vary with load characteristics.
Primary Injection Testing
If a circuit breaker is operating within the temperature rise and maximum values in the previous table, then the circuit breaker should be operating normally. If one thinks that the circuit breaker is suspect and is concerned that the circuit breaker may nuisance trip, then it is recommended that Square D Field Services be employed to run a primary injection test on the circuit breaker to determine whether or not the circuit breaker is performing per its characteristic tripping curve. Instruction Bulletin 0600IB1201 Field Testing and Maintenance Guide is a great reference for visual inspection, preventative maintenance, and performance testing of thermal magnetic and MicroLogic™ electronic trip circuit breakers.