Chapter 3
Protection for Motor-Feeders
Introduction
A motor-feeder must satisfy the general rules of NEC standards as per Article 430. This standard defines:
-
Disconnection from power supply
-
Short-circuit protection
-
Overload protection
-
Motor control or switching
A |
TeSys GV5PB / GV6PB devicen |
B |
Disconnection and short-circuit protection |
C |
Overload protection |
D |
Contactor |
E |
SDTAM thermal defect module |
Characteristics Defined by UL 489 Supplement SH
TeSys GV5PB / GV6PB devices:
-
Provide protection for direct-on-line motor-feeders and star-delta motor starters (direct-on-line starting is the most widely used type of motor-feeder).
-
Integrate the basic protections (overload, short-circuit, and phase unbalance) for the motor-feeder.
-
Allow protection and coordination of the motor-feeder components that comply with the requirements of UL 489 Supplement SH.
-
Are used to create motor-feeders with two devices.
Motor Operating States
Introduction
TeSys GV5PB / GV6PB devices consider the application to be operating as soon as the 10% of Ir pickup is crossed in a positive direction by the motor current.
Two operating states are considered:
-
Startup state
-
Steady state
Startup State
The application is considered to be in startup state according to the following criteria:
-
Start: As soon as the 10% of Ir pickup is crossed in a positive direction by the motor current.
-
End: As soon as the Id pickup equals 1.5 x Ir and the td time delay equals 10 s (non-adjustable parameters).
Exceeding the 10 s time delay does not result in tripping.
NOTE: The trip unit filters the subtransient state (first current peak of approximately 20 ms on contactor closing). This current peak is not therefore taken into account when assessing whether the Id pickup has been crossed.
Steady State
The application is considered to be in steady state according to the following criteria:
-
Start: As soon as startup ends.
-
End: As soon as the 10% of Ir pickup is crossed in a negative direction by the motor current.
Operating Diagram
The following diagrams show the two cases of transition between startup and steady state:
Operating states with current I < Id before end of td | Operating states with current I > Id at end of td |
A |
TeSys GV5PB / GV6PB devices status (green: ON position) |
B |
Contactor status (green: ON position) |
C |
Current in the motor |
D |
Operating state: startup state (green: active state) |
E |
Operating state: steady state (green: active state) |
Trip Unit Description
Introduction
The trip unit is suitable for protecting motor-feeders in standard applications. The thermal trip curves are calculated for self-ventilated motors. The adjustment dials and indications are located on the front face.
Description
TeSys GV5PB trip unit
TeSys GV6PB trip unit
A |
Micrologic 2.2 M/2.3 M electronic trip unit adjustment range |
B |
Adjustment dial for Full Load Amperes (FLA) Ir |
C |
Selection dial for the long-time protection time delay class |
D |
Adjustment dial for the short-time protection pickup Isd |
E |
Value of instantaneous protection pickup Ii |
F |
Test port |
G |
Phase unbalance |
H |
Ready LED (green) |
I |
Alarm LED (green) |
Indication LEDs
Indication LEDs on the front of the trip unit indicate its operational state.
Indication LED | Description |
Green READY LED | Blinks slowly when the electronic trip unit is ready to provide protection. |
Red ALARM LED | Overload temperature alarm LED: Shows a steady light when the thermal image of the motor exceeds 95% of the Ir setting. |
The indication LEDs function for device load currents above 30 A.
Protection Functions
The following figure and table define the protection functions performed by the trip unit:
Item |
Parameter |
Description |
Adjustable |
Default setting |
SDTAM activation |
A |
Ir |
Overload or Full Load Amperes (FLA) |
Yes |
0.4 x In |
Yes |
B |
Class |
Trip class |
Yes |
10 |
Yes |
C |
Isd |
Short-time protection pickup |
Yes |
13 x Ir |
No |
D |
tsd |
Short-time protection time delay |
No |
0.1 s |
No |
E |
Ii |
Instantaneous protection pickup |
No |
17 x In |
No |
C |
Iunbal |
Phase-unbalance protection pickup |
No |
30% |
Yes |
C |
tunbal |
Phase-unbalance protection time delay during startup |
No |
0.7 s |
Yes |
Phase-unbalance protection time delay in steady state |
No |
4 s |
Yes |
Each function is reviewed in detail on the following pages.
Setting the Protection
Set the overload or thermal protection pickup (Ir), the short-time protection pickup (Isd), and trip class (Class) by using the dials on the device.
Reflex Tripping
The GV6PB motor protection circuit breaker supports reflex tripping. The system of reflex protection breaks very high fault currents by mechanically tripping the device with a piston actuated directly by the pressure produced in the device from a short-circuit. This piston operates the opening mechanism, resulting in ultra-fast device tripping.
Overload or Thermal Protection (ANSI 49)
Introduction
Overload or thermal protection protects all types of motor applications against overload currents.
Operating Principle
Overload or thermal protection is I2t IDMT (Inverse Definite Minimum Time):
-
It incorporates the motor thermal image function.
-
It can be configured as the Ir pickup and as the trip class (Class).
Tripping curve:
Item |
Parameter |
Description |
A |
Ir |
Overload or Full Load Amperes (FLA) |
B |
Class |
Overload or thermal protection trip class |
Ir Pickup Setting Value
The overload or thermal protection pickup (Ir) is set by using a multi-position dial.
The default Ir pickup setting value is 0.4 x In (minimum dial value).
The overload or thermal protection tripping range is 1.05 ˗ C1.20 x Ir according to IEC/EN 60947-4-1 standard.
The following table shows the preset values of the adjustment dial Ir in amperes for each current rating In:
Trip unit rating In (A) |
150 A |
250 A |
400 A |
600 A |
Pickup Ir (A) |
58 | 114 | 190 | 312 |
71 | 137 | 210 | 338 | |
79 | 145 | 230 | 364 | |
86 | 155 | 250 | 390 | |
91 | 163 | 270 | 416 | |
97 | 172 | 290 | 442 | |
110 | 181 | 310 | 468 | |
119 | 210 | 330 | 494 | |
130 | 217 | 348 | 524 |
Trip Class Setting Value
The trip class (Class) is set by using an adjustment dial:
-
Class 5
-
Class 10 (default value)
-
Class 20
The trip class corresponds to the value of the tripping time for a current of 7.2 x Ir according to IEC/EN 60947-4-1 standard.
The following table shows the value of the tripping time depending on the current in the load for all three classes:
Current in the load |
Tripping time (in seconds) |
||
Class 5 |
Class 10 |
Class 20 |
|
1.5 x Ir |
96–120 |
192–240 |
320–400 |
6 x Ir |
5.2–6.5 |
10.8–13.5 |
20.8–26 |
7.2 x Ir |
4–5 |
8–10 |
16–20 |
The precision range is -20%, + 0%.
Motor Thermal Image
The model representing heat rise and cooling in a motor load is constructed according to the algorithm for calculating the thermal demand, taking account of the iron and copper losses.
The following figure represents the limit curves for the iron and copper components calculated for class 20:
A |
Limit temperature curve for copper |
B |
Limit temperature curve for iron |
C |
Tripping curve (low envelope) |
Thermal Memory
The trip unit uses a thermal memory function to protect the motor from overheating in case of repetitive low amplitude overload conditions.
Electronic protection without thermal memory function does not protect against repetitive low amplitude overload conditions because the duration of each overload above the pickup setting is too short to cause tripping. However, each overload causes a temperature rise in the installation. The cumulative effect of successive overloads can overheat the system. The thermal memory function remembers and integrates the thermal heating caused by each pickup setting overrun. The thermal memory function remembers the thermal heating values for 20 minutes before or after tripping.
Example: Comparison of the heat rise calculation without thermal image (diagram A) and with thermal image (diagram B):
0 |
Load control (cyclical) |
1 |
Motor temperature |
2 |
Thermal level calculated without thermal image (diagram A), with thermal image (diagram B) |
3 |
Overload or thermal protection level |
With thermal image, the trip unit adds the thermal effect of successive current pulses. Tripping occurs based on the actual thermal state of the motor.
Cooling Fan
The thermal image of the motor is calculated taking account of the fact that the motor is self-cooled (fan mounted on the shaft end).
Short-Time Protection (ANSI 51)
Introduction to Short Term Protection (ANSI 51)
Short-time protection protects all types of motor applications against short-circuit currents.
Short-time protection lets through motor starting currents but protects cables and motor starter devices and allows not to oversize them (useful for wide range settings devices).
Operating Principle
Isd Pickup Setting Value
The short-time protection pickup Isd is set by using a multi-position dial. The setting value is expressed in multiples of Ir. |
Step | Action |
1 |
Set the long-time protection first: the setting pickup is Ir (A). |
2 |
Turn the Isd adjustment dial to the value required. The setting range is 5 to 13 x Ir in steps of Ir. |
3 |
Isd is set to Ir (A) x Isd setting. |
The precision range is +/-15%.
tsd Time Delay Value
The time delay cannot be adjusted.
-
The hold time is 20 ms.
-
The maximum breaking time is 60 ms.
Instantaneous Protection (ANSI 50)
Introduction
Instantaneous protection is fixed: the pickup value is determined by the current rating In. Protection is instantaneous.
Operating Principle
Ii Pickup Value
The Ii pickup value is 15 x In (trip unit rating In corresponds to the maximum Ir setting).
The precision range is +/-15%.
The maximum breaking time is 30 ms.
Phase Unbalance Protection (ANSI 46)
Introduction
Description
Phase unbalance protection:
-
Calculates the current unbalance for each phase, compared to the average current, expressed as a percentage:
-
Compares the value of the maximum current unbalance with the Iunbal protection pickup.
The following diagram shows a maximum positive unbalance on phase 2:
If the maximum current unbalance value is higher than the phase unbalance protection Iunbal pickup, the tunbal time delay is actuated.
Phase unbalance protection cannot be deactivated.
Phase unbalance protection is activated during startup and in steady state.
Operating Principle
The phase unbalance (or phase loss) protection trips if the current unbalance exceeds the 30% fixed pickup Iunbal during a fixed tunbal time delay. The tunbal time delay differs according to the motor operating conditions:
-
Start-up phase: tunbal = 0.7 s
-
Steady state phase: tunbal = 4 s
The phase unbalance protection does not trip if the current unbalance falls below the Iunbal pickup before the end of the fixed tunbal time delay.